A court decision is a ruling made by a judge in a case. A ruling can be anything from the outcome of a trial to a final ruling on a case’s appeal. The court’s decision will have consequences for all parties involved in the case. For example, if a person does not pay a debt judgment that creditor can collect from them. The decision will be entered in the record and appear on the defendant’s credit report. The decision can also have a legal effect that will impact the defendant’s future.
A judge’s decision can be based on evidence presented in testimony or in documents. A judge can also base their decisions on a law or a previous court decision. Generally, the more convincing the evidence is in a case, the more likely the court will rule in favor of one side or another.
When a majority of Justices agree on the outcome of a case, they may write an opinion about the reasoning behind the decision. This is called a majority or plurality opinion. It is important to count the number of Justices who signed the main opinion to find out whether it was a majority or plurality opinion. Justices who do not agree with the decision can write a concurring or dissenting opinion. A Justice’s dissent can be influential in overturning the majority decision. Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote more than 120 dissenting opinions.
The legal system adheres to the doctrine of precedent, which means that a judge will usually follow the principles established in earlier cases with similar facts and legal issues. The rulings in those cases become precedent unless they are overturned by legislation or a higher court’s ruling.
About the Author
